The Competitive Urge

DownloadedFileThe competitive urge is a curious phenomenon.  At a social gathering in India, I recall teaching my neighbor’s eight-year-old son how to play the tabletop “football” game.  This involves each player taking turns pushing a coin across the table.  Getting the coin to hang over the edge of the table without falling off is a “touchdown.”

The boy was excited to learn the game and he immediately wanted to play against me.  I played with restraint and allowed him to win the game.  The moment he hit the winning shot, his eyes lit up, he jumped straight into the air and shouted, “I am champion!  I am champion!” — to the great amusement of the other kids and adults crowding around us to watch the contest.

We played a second game and this time I was less generous.  As I aimed the potential winning shot, I paused to consider the emotional impact on the boy.  How would he handle losing his “championship” in front of everyone?  I considered intentionally missing the shot, but I didn’t want to lose to him twice, so I went for the win and got it.

To my surprise the boy’s eyes lit up again and he jumped up into the air just as before, this time shouting, “You are second champion!  I am first champion!”  Our competitive urges, his and mine, were curious indeed.

I came from a family well acquainted with competitive sports. My father and my mother were coaches who believed in the noblest aspects of sports. They made it clear that they wanted me to play for the love of the game and to be a good sportsman: humble in victory and gracious in defeat.

I professed agreement with their ethic, but deep down I didn’t embrace it.  In certain ways I was a coach’s dream: a cooperative, hard working player who never gave up.  I wanted to win, or so I thought.  But winning was not nearly as satisfying as I expected it to be.  I discovered I was ambitious for something else.

I didn’t want merely to win; I wanted to feel superior to my opponent.  In high school basketball games, I would stare at my adversary with real contempt; I considered him beneath me.  Even on my own team it mattered to me, not only that I worked hard, but also that I worked harder than everyone else.  I hated to lose to anyone.  I hated to lose far more than I valued winning.

Losing represented painful inferiority, and a hate-to-lose approach to achievement used my fear of feeling inferior to motivate higher performances.  This seemed to work for me at first, helping me push for the extra effort that sometimes was the difference between victory and defeat.

But a hate-to-lose mentality as a motivator became a problem because it made winning incidental and eventually irrelevant.  When not-losing is more important than everything else, then everything else, such giving your best effort or winning, are no longer the point of playing.  For me winning became only a postponement of self-doubt that would arise the next time I needed to compete again and defend against a new assault of inferiority.

What was worse, I knew plenty of coaches who actively advocated the hate-to-lose approach.  With contorted faces and impassioned voices they’d tell the team that to succeed as an athlete, “You gotta HATE to LOSE!”  This mentality is very prevalent on all levels of sport, from pee wees to the pros.  It produces fear-driven athletes who have lost their first love of the game.

This perplexed and depressed me.  I avoided sports for a while, but something drew me back into the game.  Eventually I developed an understanding of athletics that was transformative for me in other areas of life as well.

At the bottom of this issue is the struggle for self-definition, for an answer to the question “Who am I?”   An alternative approach to the fear-based comparison game involves abandoning the competitive urge as a primary source of motivation.  This means embracing a mindset of self discovery that’s not dependent in any way on one’s relative rank to other human beings.  This approach is very hard to do, and is so foreign a way of thinking to most that it is often ridiculed as weak, foolish or unambitious.

Struggle and striving are still necessary – the ranking as a basis for identity is not.  It is essential to encounter resistance from forces larger than ourselves that challenge us in ways we can’t fully control or predict.  The self-definition born of true knowledge of our absolute limitations is, paradoxically, freeing.  Freeing, in part, because it allows us to identify with others instead of comparing with others.

Identification with others based on our common limitations enables us to love them rather than see them as competitors, and therefore threats.  The fear of losing vanishes in this approach because in this way resistance and even loss becomes the teachers that propel us far higher than the conventional ideas of competitive success.

Stepping out of this hierarchical way of thinking is frightening, which is why it is far easier to think in a competitive way to justify ourselves.  The competitive urge as a basis for our sense of self is a calamity.  The day we stop trying to justify ourselves through comparison with others is a great day in our lives.

This entry was posted in happiness, India, meaningful life, philosophy, recovery, sobriety, spirituality, travel and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to The Competitive Urge

  1. MSheshera says:

    This is great! 🙂
    Also, kind of off topic, but it is Jonathan Haidt says in his talk on TED “Sports is to war as pornography is to sex. We get to exercise some ancient, ancient drives.” (
    What do you think that means?

    • jjanuszewski says:

      Thanks, Mr. Sheshera. That’s an intriguing thought about primary drives. I will take a look at that link and get back to you with my thoughts. Jerry Januszewski

    • jjanuszewski says:

      Mr. Sheshera, thanks for the Ted link. Interesting take on moral foundations. Jonathan Haidt’s analogy between sports and pornography doesn’t make sense to me, especially in the context of his talk. It seems to me that sports is a potentially healthy sublimation of inclinations for conflict, while the use of pornography is not healthy and involves no sublimation at all. See this fascinating article on porn: JJ

  2. bgood says:

    alrighty mr, new testament 🙂
    i agree that smiting your opponents and turning them into pillars of salt might not leave you as happy a buddhist lotus flower but i really question whether or not you will find the amazing athletic performances that were delivered by jordan, rose, lambert, rice, lewis and other elite performers and more to the point i wonder if even those not gifted with genetic talent, would rise above otherwise mediocre performance if not driven by a desire to competitively establish superiority.
    not saying you will be happy, but am simply observing that the ruthless ones seem to really garner a different level of performance.

    can you truly commit your all to the struggle and strive to your optimum capacity if you are focused on empathy and sympathy and identifying with others based on common limitations? why would you want to embrace limitation as an identity?

    i truly believe that it is easier for most people to step out of the competitive urge because they are reluctant to risk losing in the process. that is why there are so few elite folks performing and why most people are captive to a herd existence. look at all the capitualtion to struggle that most folks give in to instead of working hard at being their best. few folks ever worked as hard as you used to on the basketball court jj, they all admired you for what you brought to the game but they were lazy and you were not.

    you might be happier now embracing and sharing their limitations but are you really actualizing your capacity as an athlete. even an old one 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s